Hannah Sweet (Melissa Anschutz) is in a destructive spiral that threatens her career as a country music star. She hasn't been home to the sleepy lakeside town of Lost Heart since she ran away as a teenager. But when her estranged father, Harris, dies amidst claims of UFO encounters, Hannah begrudgingly returns for the funeral. She meets Milo (Don Most), a forward-thinking, conspiracy-loving pastor who tries to lead Hannah towards reconciliation with her family, especially her reclusive hippy mother Alma (Victoria Jackson).